Farm near bay Farm near bay

Performance-Based Financing for Sustainable Water Management

Generating Agroecosystems Solutions
Generating Agroecosystems Solutions

Program Contact

Dr. Kathy Boomer
kboomer@foundationfar.org

Dr. Peter Adriaens headshot

Dr. Peter Adriaens

University of Michigan

Year Awarded  2022

FFAR award amount   $600,000

Total award amount   $1,200,000

Location   Ann Arbor, MI

Program   Seeding Solutions

Matching Funders   Great Lakes Protection Fund

  • Agroecosystems

Can Financial Markets Incentivize Sustainable Agriculture Practices?

Though fertilizer runoff from agricultural fields can degrade water quality, the demand for greater crop yields often stymies effective solutions. The United States Farm Bill does incentivize sustainable practices, but its impact is limited.

Since private capital outpaces public funding in agriculture, institutional agricultural bond buyers, agricultural banks and farm credit institutions have an opportunity to develop or modify financial products to encourage adoption of environmentally sustainable practices. Through improved monitoring of fertilizer emissions from farms and applying a carbon-equivalent lens to nutrients, financiers can better understand their disclosure requirements and loan risks related to water pollution, enabling them to incentivize efforts around mitigation and sustainability.

However, agricultural financing and lending risk models currently lack a consistent or meaningful water quality metric and financial sustainability policies are regulated through disclosure of carbon risks. To fill that gap and explore the potential of this incentives strategy, researchers led by Dr. Peter Adriaens, professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Michigan, are linking a nutrient modeling and monitoring system in the Lake Huron drainage basin to financing through the carbon market. They will use this information to develop sustainability-linked financial products that determine fertilizer nutrient runoff risk based on measurements that can be attributed to specific farms or farming practices.

Dr. Adriaens participates on Climate Week Agriculture Finance panel
Dr. Adriaens participating at New York Climate Week panel on Agricultural Finance panel. Courtesy of Peter Adriaens.

Developing Transparency About Farm Operational Risks

Financial products that support environmentally sustainable practices are increasingly in demand. In one example, agriculture financing meets this demand by measuring a farm’s carbon emissions, which are disclosed in financial products like loans. This helps lenders assess a farm’s true value by providing transparency about the benefits of increased yield versus the environmental costs of cleanup, fines or legal liability for pollution.

In this project, researchers are determining how nutrient impact on water quality can be similarly tracked through embedded carbon equivalents, linked to individual farms and used to assess financial risk and opportunity for lenders. The financial value chain of farm credit links farms to Wall Street institutional investors via agricultural banks. By creating transparency and disclosure around Scope 3 carbon associated with nutrient emissions, lenders can determine the risks of lending to individual farms, allowing them reprice interest rates and loan terms.

Under current loan structures, the benefit of greater fertilizer use to increase yield outweighs the benefits of sustainable management practices to reduce environmental impacts. But by linking lending to a farm’s fertilizer runoff, calculated as carbon equivalents, the sustainability profile of farm operations becomes an input in the financial value chain, meeting financial disclosure requirements under the Task Force for Climate-Related Financial Disclosures. With this knowledge, the researchers intend to engage with farmers, lenders, rating agencies and commodity buyers to develop loan structuring and other financial products that support sustainable water management by encouraging lower fertilizer use and other soil health and conservation practices. Farms practicing sustainable agriculture can then enjoy less expensive loan terms because of the lower lending risk, possibly repriced crop insurance rates, and capture carbon credits resulting from their practices.

Details About this Research

array(1) {
  ["latest"]=>
  array(3) {
    ["tax"]=>
    NULL
    ["research"]=>
    array(3) {
      ["title"]=>
      string(0) ""
      ["image"]=>
      bool(false)
      ["promo_text"]=>
      string(37) "Read the latest project breakthroughs"
    }
    ["latest"]=>
    array(3) {
      ["title"]=>
      string(10) "The Latest"
      ["sections_show"]=>
      array(4) {
        [0]=>
        string(8) "insights"
        [1]=>
        string(4) "news"
        [2]=>
        string(6) "events"
        [3]=>
        string(13) "breakthroughs"
      }
      ["additional_past_events"]=>
      string(0) ""
    }
  }
}

The Latest

Insights

Our Insights highlight unique perspectives from across the food and agriculture community.

See all Insights

The Aim For Healthy, Productive & Environmentally Friendly, Southeastern Beef Calves

Federico Tarnonsky

FFAR Fellow (2022-2025), University of Florida

Hispanic Heritage Month

Using Artificial Intelligence to Calculate GHGs at the Individual Farm Level

Kaiyu Guan

Dr. Kaiyu Guan

University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign

Data for Dairy: Research to Guide Farmers in Their Sustainability Journey

Reza Afshar

Reza Afshar

Vice President, Soil, Feed and Water Research at Dairy Management Inc.

Data-Driven Fungicide Decisions

Vini Garnica

2022-2025 FFAR Fellow, NC State University

Time Teaches Biosecurity Importance

Kevin Schulz

Kevin Schulz

Editor, The Farmer/Farm Progress

Greener Cattle Initiative is Game Changer for Dairy’s Future

Dr. Juan Tricarico

Dr. Juan Tricarico

Senior Vice President, Environmental Research, Dairy Management Inc.

Cracking the Code of Texture:

Heeduk Oh

FFAR Fellow, NC State University

Entrepreneur Attributes Kirchner HBCU Fellowship to Career Success

Kwame Terra

Kwame Terra MPH

Kirchner Fellowship HBCU 2021 Cohort

Reducing Enteric Methane Emissions from Dairy Cattle

Francisco Penagaricano headshot

Dr. Francisco Peñagaricano and Dr. Guillermo Martinez Boggio

Building Diversity & Inclusion in the Agriculture Technology Venture Capital Industry

LaKisha Odom, Ph.D.

Scientific Program Director Sustaining Vibrant Agroecosystems

Unlocking Peanut Potential

Samuele Lamon

FFAR Fellow, University of Georgia

Advancing Ecosystem Service Markets for Sustainable Farming

LaKisha Odom & DJ May

Feeding Bees Through Diversity

Riley Reed

FFAR Fellow, Washington State University

Precision Agriculture Tools for Livestock Production

Caleb J. Grohmann

FFAR Fellow, University of Missouri

The Next Frontier for Biotechnology & the Future of Forestry

Samantha Surber

FFAR Fellow, University of Georgia

A Place for Everyone in Agriculture

Dr. LaKisha Odom & Jocelyn Hittle

Transforming Agriculture with Data and Artificial Intelligence

Shiang-Wan Chin, FFAR Fellow

Cornell University

Closing the Loop

Madeline Desjardins, FFAR Fellow

Washington State University

News

The latest news and updates from FFAR.

See all News

ROAR Funding Protects Strawberries from Dangerous Pathogen

Efficient Fertilizer Consortium Seeks Research to Evaluate Enhanced Efficiency Fertilizer Impact Globally

FFAR’s Dr. LaKisha Odom Selected for Two Prestigious Agriculture Industry Awards

FFAR Aims to Help Farmers Manage Manure More Sustainably & Profitably

Seeding Solutions Grant Promotes Clean Water Through Performance-Based Financing

FFAR Seeding Solutions Grant Evaluates the Benefits of Converting Row Crops to Perennial Forage Systems

Seeding Solutions Grant Provides Decision Support Tool for Extreme Weather Events

Seeding Solutions Grant to Preserve Groundwater and Economically Benefit Growers

FFAR & Eight Member Organizations Commit $8.45 Million to Efficient Fertilizer Consortium

Hemp Research Consortium Grant Examines Biopesticides for Hemp Treatment

Seeding Solutions Grant Developing Tomato Resistance to Parasitic Weed

Seeding Solutions Grant Develops Cotton-Based Precision Irrigation

FFAR and North Carolina State Announce 2024 FFAR Fellows

Crops of the Future Grant Improves Stress Tolerance in Carrots

AgMission Grant Evaluates Successful Incentives for Persistent Cover Crop Adoption

ICASA Award Addresses Antimicrobial Stewardship for Bovine Respiratory Disease

FFAR Grant to Improve Sorghum & Strengthen Nutritional Security

FFAR & FoodShot Global Announce GroundBreaker Prize Winners in Water Research

Swine Wean-to-Harvest Biosecurity Program Funds Additional Research

FFAR Names Sixth Cohort of Veterinary Fellows

Breakthroughs

Tools, technologies and strategies from the research we fund.

See all Breakthroughs

New Study Shows AI & Supercomputing Can Quantify Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Individual Farms

Breakthrough for FFAR Grant Quantifies Organic Carbon to Improve Agricultural Productivity

Loyalty Shopper Card Intervention Creates Behavior Change

Breakthrough for Individually-targeted incentives, diet quality and health outcomes among adults

Developing an Extensive Database of US Groundwater Wells

Breakthrough for Achieving Sustainable Groundwater Management Through Innovative Governance & Optimal Agricultural Water Use Under Conflicting Objectives

Building Collaborations for Technology-Driven Solutions in Agriculture

Breakthrough for Open Technology Ecosystem for Agricultural Management (OpenTEAM)

Building Food System Interventions to Support Urban & Rural Communities

Breakthrough for Integrating Community and Modeling Efforts to Evaluate Impacts and Tradeoffs of Food System Interventions

Unlocking Genetic Heat Tolerance in Cattle

Breakthrough for Precision Bred Adaptation of Elite Taurine Breeds of Beef & Dairy Cattle

Increased Fiber, Same Great Taste

Breakthrough for Increasing Dietary Fiber in Wheat Crop

Diagnosing Coffee Leaf Rust & Slowing Its Spread

Breakthrough for Protecting Coffee from Leaf Rust Disease

Connecting Growers & Markets

Breakthrough for FFAR Grant Develops Tools to Predict Consumer Demand, Reduce Food Waste

Accelerating Crop Development with Improved Haploid Fertility

Breakthrough for Accelerated Development of Crops of the Future

Documenting Adaptive Multi-Paddock Grazing’s Benefits

Breakthrough for Quantifying the Advantages of Multi-Paddock (AMP) Grazing in the U.S. Southeast & Northern Great Plains

RIPE Researchers Prove Bioengineering Better Photosynthesis Increases Yields in Food Crops for the First Time

Breakthrough for Realizing Increased Photosynthetic Efficiency (RIPE) Reinvestment

Launch of Eco-Harvest, a program rewarding producers for regenerative agriculture practices

Breakthrough for Ecosystem Services Market Consortium

Radiography could transform poultry breeding

Breakthrough for FFAR Awards $1.4 Million to Purdue University, University of California, Davis and University of Edinburgh Researchers to Improve Health and Productivity of Egg-Laying Hens

Research Pinpoints Why Dairy Cows Produce Less Milk in Warm Weather and Develops Nutrition-Based Solution

Breakthrough for FFAR Grant Helps Heat-Stressed Dairy Cows Weather Increasing Temperatures

The Irrigation Innovation Consortium & Parallel 41 Network: Building a path to data-driven management

Groundwater Fluctuations Impact Grain Yields

Breakthrough for FFAR Awards $2.4 Million to Eight Early-Career Research Faculty Members for Innovative Research Projects

Getting to the Root of the Problem: Fastidious Pathogens

Breakthrough for A Novel Bioassay for Culturing and Characterizing Fastidious Phytopathogens

Report on Interventions to Reduce Consumer Food Waste

Breakthrough for Understanding & Reducing Consumer Food Waste

Feed Additives Stop Viral Disease Spread, Researchers Find

Breakthrough for FFAR-Funded Research Finds Feed Additives Stop the Spread of Viral Diseases

Want to do more to support Agroecosystem?